We use cookies on this site to provide you with an informative and engaging experience and also to help us to continually improve our site for you. Without allowing cookies certain features of the site will not be available. To learn more about how we use cookies, please view our cookie policy. By clicking on ‘I AGREE’, you consent to our use of cookies on this device in accordance with our policy.

Logo of Wolters Kluwer, Kluwer Law Online
European Public Law
Search content button

Home > All journals > European Public Law > 29(2) >

Judicial Review of EU Soft Law Acts as a Matter of the Rule of Law [pre-publication]

Cover image ofEuropean Public Law
Judicial Review of EU Soft Law Acts as a Matter of the Rule of Law [pre-publication]


European Public Law
Volume 29, Issue 2 (2023) pp. 181 – 198



Abstract

As constantly repeated by the Court of Justice, the European Union is a union based on the rule of law, which means, among others, that all acts of its institutions are subject to review of their compatibility with the ‘higher law’, in particular the Treaties, general principles of law and fundamental rights. In other words, no act of an EU institution can escape the judicial review performed by the Court of Justice. However, a question arises whether this rule applies or should apply even to EU acts having a character of soft law. Although they do not have binding legal force or do not induce binding legal effects, they are still results of the exercise of public powers, and hence they should be under the judicial control as well. Nonetheless, the current system of judicial review seems insufficient to provide such a control. The action for annulment is not available, and the preliminary reference on validity, which allows for the judicial review of soft law, presents an imperfect alternative because of various obstacles. This article argues that, in the name of the rule of law, it is desirable to change the current settings and to allow for judicial review of soft law in all possible procedural channels.


Keywords

EU soft law, rule of law, Court of Justice, judicial review, action for annulment, preliminary reference on validity


Extract




Subscribe to this journal

Interested in a subscription? Contact our sales team

Browse by practice area
Share
Stay up to date


RSSETOC